Miranda NG Official Community Forum
Forum for English speaking Miranda NG users => Miranda NG general talk => Topic started by: calabar on 27 06 2014, 10:08:46
-
Ever since I use Miranda and communicate with GTalk users, I use the Jabber Plugin.
It works fine, but it is limited (no file transfer, no group chat, etc...).
Now I'm wondering if exists any alternative that allow me to improve my gtalk experience.
The passage should be painless, I'd like to preserve all my present contacts without re-insert them manually or ask for authorization again, if possible.
Thanks.
-
mmm... ok, no luck about that.
Maybe someone can answer to a question: the limits I described above are known or it is possible to around them in some way? Someone of you is able to use group chat or transfer files between gtalk/hangouts and Miranda NG?
PS: still have the problem of offline messages sent to my gmail instead then to Miranda, has something changed in the last year?
-
There is no file transfers in GTalk AFAIK. And hangouts - it's something with closed specifications.
-
Could you explain in more details?
I could open a feature request in Miranda UserVoice, but I want to be sure that the request make some sense.
At the moment, I miss: - Offline message, retrieve that in gmail is uncomfortable and makes the history confusing.
- File transfer: send and receive files with a contact that uses hangouts (or any other compatible client). The chance to send files to the contact's email would be very appreciated too (send a file as it was a file transfer, but automatically converted in email and received as email from the recipient), and could be a good workaround if file transfer should not work properly.
- Join or create a chat session with multiple hangouts contacts.
- Maybe something other that eludes me in this moment.
Thanks.
-
There are no specks for hangouts - it is google's proprietary service and we don't do reverse engineering anymore. We write plugins for services that provide tools for doing so. They do not provide any API or tools for working with hangouts. Google Talk (XMPP) works with hangouts as good as google lets it work. I'm not sure that anything else can be done on this matter.
-
I've found this (http://www.zdnet.com/google-moves-away-from-the-xmpp-open-messaging-standard-7000015918/) interesting article that explain what google did with the transition to Hangouts.
So, the only hope is that google will open his protocol allowing to other clients to use their main features.
That's a pity, I thought that google was following the "open" way with Hangouts too, but I was wrong.
Thanks!
-
There are no specks for hangouts - it is google's proprietary service and we don't do reverse engineering anymore.
Why do you refuse to do reverse-engineering for Hangouts?
Isn't the Facebook plugin also based on some level of reverse-engineering (that uses the HTTP interface and acts just like a browser)?
It would be really good to have Hangouts integrated into Miranda NG. At least the chat and groupchat features. Too bad Google wants their users to be dependent on browsers or their proprietary technology that is usually bloated and resource-hungry.
-
Why do you refuse to do reverse-engineering for Hangouts?
We don't have time and people that willing to do it - it's a long process.
-
If there will be some working open source implementation of Hangouts in other software (like Pidgin or similar), then (if it will be in C/C++) it would be much easier to adapt it for Miranda NG too. But obviously no one here is willing / interested enough to do the reverse-engineering thing of it himself :-)
-
There are LINE for pidgin
http://altrepo.eu/git/purple-line
Even with this no one willing to adapt it to Miranda
-
We don't have time and people that willing to do it - it's a long process.
I can understand, and it is a pity for me. :(
I use hangouts and the lack of a proper plugin is uncomfortable for me. At the moment I use Jabber, but the lack of support for offline messages (and the related incomplete history) is very limiting.
There are LINE for pidgin ... Even with this no one willing to adapt it to Miranda
Wrong topic? Here we are speaking about Hangouts, not line.
-
There are LINE for pidgin
http://altrepo.eu/git/purple-line
Even with this no one willing to adapt it to Miranda
Well, even if there is protocol source code from some other software, it is still time-comsuming and not-easy process to rewrite it for Miranda. So it still must be worth it (e.g. it must be popular protocol or the dev itself must be interested in it).
-
Wrong topic? Here we are speaking about Hangouts, not line
Just for example if it will be on pidgin at first it will not necessary will be on miranda also. Hard to understand?
No asian chinese, japanese peoples in develop team to resurrect QQ and adapt Line. Doubt that steam or sametime are more popular.
-
Just for example if it will be on pidgin at first it will not necessary will be on miranda also. Hard to understand?
Frankly I haven't understood yet... ???
But don't worry, maybe my poor English.
-
The bottom line is: Someone Has To Do It.
Are YOU volunteering?
-
we have facebook chat, do we need hangouts?
until facebook plugin works, i think not
-
Why using hangouts? Probably because not all people uses Facebook or whatsapp and have their contacts on Hangouts.
Unfortunately the support on Miranda is very limited, the last issue is that if I add a contact using his/her google mail account, it results ever offline.
If I use the "encrypted" id provided by hangouts (I suppose it has been created to protect contact's email) I see the contact's status correctly.
The strange thing is that it is true only for contacts added in the last period, while old contacts works fine with their unencrypted user name.
-
really don't know somebody who use hangouts
don't know anybody who not use facebook
-
Now you know one ;)
And I ensure you I'm not the only one.
Maybe the different region, maybe the different age. Maybe simply different people. The world is beautiful because it is various.
-
im on facebook to advertise pages, all polish are on facebook, in Poland hangouts aren't popular
i looked hangouts for me it's only simple messanger one from many in the world
with very expensive rates to call phones
0,54-0,94pln Hangouts
0,29pln GSM
0,03-13pln VOIP
without miranda support for me hangouts is useless & can die
-
That's why I hope for a better support from Miranda. :)
At the moment I use it with a limited support (enough for a basic usage, anyway), but there are some main feature that I think should be available, such as receive massages arrived when offline, fix the issue of offline contacts if added with their unencrypted user name and maybe an history database synchronization.